Page 36 of Trick or Treat
Blade's fingers slide into my pussy, thrusting hard as he curls them against the spot that causes my legs to tremble. Saint's fingers suddenly start to painfully slide into my ass, thrusting ferociously to keep up with his brother's rhythm and attempting to push me over the edge. They’re out just as quickly as he pushed them into me, providing some relief from the burning, stretching pain. I breathe once when I’m empty, but it doesn’t last. With Blade's fingers still in my pussy, he inserts more until his entire hand is inside of me, forming a fist that he viciously pounds in and out,making god awful slurping and suction noises that echo in my ears in the dead of night.
Saint puts his fingers back in my ass, this time adding more than two like he did before. They both brutally abuse my body however they fucking want, making a mess of me in the process. As soon as I open my mouth to scream, one of them shoves Saint's knife handle into it and forces my lips shut tightly around it; however, I’m unable to see which one is doing it.
I close my eyes and let my climax rip through me as I lay here being finger fucked, fisted, and made to lick the handle of the blade clean, silently praying for this nightmare to end, even though the pleasure coursing through my body as my belly contracts feels so fucking good.
Blade
After giving Scarlett a fresh shirt to wear and doing our best to clean up her bloody, battered body, we stowed our masks back in our packs and retreated into the woods, this time looking for Melanie. I cast a quick glance at her to see if she even understands what happened back there, but based on the wild expression in her eyes, I don’t think there’s any chance of that happening given how far she’s already gone.
"Where are we going?" she asks, my gaze fixed on the vivid bite marks and dried blood smeared all over her neck from where I choked and bit her.
"We're trying to find Melanie next. I wanna see what you two can dotogether,"I confess to her as the idea makes my cock throb.
Saint smirks, holding her elbowtightly in his grip as he guides her through the dark woods. Knowing she’s with Riley and knowing exactly where they are, I lead the way in their direction, pretending to find them by chance. I smirk as I notice the limp in sinner's walk, a chuckle slipping from my throat as I recall how we annihilated her back there, fisting her pussy before our cocks were even inside of her. We're trying to get her ready for when we'rebothinside her.
"Are you okay, Scarlett?" I ask, grabbing the back of her neck.
"Yeah, great." As she speaks, she fixes her gaze on the horizon.
I come to a halt when I notice the gleam of Riley's blade and place a finger to my lips as I pull sinner against my chest. "Shh, look over there... There are two of them."I raise my knife and aim it at Riley and Melanie.
"What do we do now that we've found them?" she asks with interest as her lips swell into a devilishly seductive grin.
"Take this and draw them out."As I give her my knife, I nod my head in their direction in anticipation of her response.
She takes it, shuffles over to them, and with a trembling hand, points the knife at her friend. Saint and I chuckle as we watch her approach the tree and actually insert the point into Melanie's arm, drawing blood immediately.
"Oww!" Melanie yells and leaps to her feet, clutching her arm, blood dripping through her fingers from a small but noticeable cut. "You cut me!"
"Yeah, but I found you!" Scarlett yells, laughing with abandon as she swings the knife around. Riley jumps out too, pretending to surrender.
"Alright, time to accept your punishment, Melanie." Saint smirks at her as he pulls Scarlett back against his chest.
"What did you have to do, Scar?" Her gaze wanders over Scarlett's body, widening in surprise at the outfit change and noticing the dried blood on her arms and legs.
"They f-"
"That's for her to know, Melanie. Everyone's is different. Don't worry about it."
"Give your friend a kiss for us." Riley orders her, sliding the point of his knife under her chin to lift her head. Her eyes widened in surprise.
"What?"
"You fucking heard me. Kiss Scarlett,now."Saint rams Scarlett into Melanie, and as the three of us watch with frenzied hunger, she slowly moves her mouth to kiss Scarlett's soft lips.
"Grab her pussy, Scarlett," Riley yells as he starts stroking his cock while watching the two girls make out.
He moves his knife away from Melanie and puts it on Scarlett, as if she hasn't had enough knife play tonight. He grins, dragging it along her spine and making her shiver as she starts rubbing Melanie's pussy.
"Blade, kiss your brother for me," he orders me, a grin on his face as he jerks himself.
Knowing we are not real brothers, I move in on Saint and seize his lips, shoving my tongue down his throat for a quick taste of him. It’s not like we’ve never kissed or fucked before.
But I pull back and smack Riley across the side of his head, glaring at him as I wipe Saint's spit from my lips. "You don't order me around, mother fucker. If I want to kiss Saint, I will. If I want to fuck Saint, I will. You order your bitch around,not me.Got it?"
"Yeah, Jesus. It's just a fucking game."
As much as I would like to sit here and watch this, I’m more interested in Scarlett than Melanie. And, knowing there’s one more participant out there who needs to be dealt with, I signal Saint to grab sinner so we can go deal with him. After all, I want her involved in his punishment. It's only fitting.