Page 69 of Broken Pieces

“Mad, keep her quiet. The only sounds she should be making are the ones we force out of her.”

“Open up, baby. Time for another taste of your big brother's cock.” I want to tell them that I wasn’t lying, but I can’t help but obey him and I open my mouth, eager to taste him again.

“Let's find out if she was lying or not then.” Max says as he pulls out after only getting a few inches inside me. I moan around Maddox’s cock trying to tell him not to stop. "Either way, she'll soon know not to lie to us ever again."

Suddenly, Max thrusts back inside me in one long movement, filling meup completely.

I’ve fucked myself deep with my vibrator before, but it was nowhere near as big as Max’s cock and he stretches my pussy painfully around him.

Tears well in my eyes, making the blindfold feel worse against them. I try to thrash my head to get them to stop and slow down, to untie me and give me just one minute to adjust to them, but I only end up choking more on Maddox’s cock.

“Fuck, slow down, little whore, I know you love sucking on your big brother’s cock, but we’re both filling your pussy up tonight, not your mouth.”

Max slowly drags his cock out of me then his icy cold voice says, “There’s no blood.”

“What?” Maddox sounds more disappointed than angry and it makes me feel bad for disappointing him at all.

He grabs a fistful of my hair and pulls me off his cock. Then he drags the blindfold up and I squeeze my eyes shut as the light burns my eyes.

Once I get used to it, I see Maddox in all his naked glory in front of me. I’ve never seen the whole package like this before, only ever seen bits and pieces of them naked and I had to mentally put the picture together in my mind.

Now it’s there in all its perfection. My eyes trail from his big cock, up over his abs then they settle on his chest. He has a new tattoo. I look closer and see it’s of flowers—no,violets,growing out of a skull.

He got a tattoo for me?

“Who did you give it to?”

“What?” I blink as I look at his stern face.

“Who took your virginity, Violet? It was meant for us,” Max says from behind me.

“No one. I didn’t lie. I took it myself. When I couldn’t bring myself to go home, I waited for both of you. Hoping you’d make the first move. When neither of you came for me, I knew that was it for us. So rather than have my first time be with some random guy, I used a toy on myself.”

20

Maddox

“God, I hate that fucking thing.”

Who does that?

Fucks themselves with a dildo when they have two perfectly good cocks waiting for them at home.

All she had to do was fucking visit.

I’m pissed off, but not as much as I thought I’d be. As long as she’s not lying then she’s still ours.

Who am I kidding?If she had fucked every guy on campus she’d still be ours.

I’m not sure about Max, but I know I’ve only made such a big deal about wanting her virginity because I was scared we'd already lost her.

Still, I can’t believe that fucking piece of plastic took it. I should have burnt it along with the other one, rather than tossing them in the trash.

“If you’re lying—”

“She’s not. I saw the culprit,” I cut Max off and he stares me down, like he’s trying to figure out if I’m telling the truth.

That’s never happened before. He always just knows.